Weber Smoque XL Pellet Smoker Review

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

A pellet smoker is an argument about attention. The machine holds a temperature so the cook does not have to. What it costs is the ability to sear.

The Smoque XL takes that bargain and makes it bigger. Weber publishes 918 square inches across two levels, 595 of them on the main grate.

What it does not do is raise the ceiling. The maximum stays 500, the same figure the line carries. This model buys area rather than reach.

918 sq inTotal cooking area, two levels
595 sq inPrimary grate, where a brisket sits
500Maximum temperature published
2 probesMeat probes in the carton

First Impressions of the Weber Smoque XL

The proportions are barrel-on-legs, done in gloss black. Lid closed, it measures 44.5 inches tall and 50.75 wide.

A chrome handle runs the width of the lid. A second handle sits on the left end for positioning.

The hopper hangs off the right side with the controller set into its face. There is an LCD, a dial and a row of buttons.

A red stripe runs along the front below the cook box. It is the only colour on an otherwise entirely black machine.

Two all-weather wheels sit under the right legs. The left side stands on feet, so moving it means tilting and walking.

At 110 pounds it is a two-person delivery rather than a two-person carry. Weber also wants 60 inches of headroom to open the lid.

That last figure is worth checking before buying. A smoker tucked under a low porch roof will not open.

The hopper placement is worth a thought too. It sits on the right, so the smoker wants clearance on that side for refilling.

Key Features of the Weber Smoque XL

  • 918 square inches, shown as its parts. Weber publishes 595 on the primary grate and 323 on the warming rack. Those sum exactly to the headline.
  • Weber Connect with a Rapid React PID. An LCD controller sets the temperature and the PID holds it. Weber claims temperature in 15 minutes or less under stated lab conditions.
  • Two meat probes in the box. Not an accessory, not a bundle. Both arrive with the smoker.
  • Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. The Weber Connect app monitors and controls the smoker remotely.
  • SmokeBoost. A setting that holds low smoking temperatures to push more smoke into the food. Weber attaches no figure to it.
  • SmoqueVent. A system Weber says circulates smoke around the food for browning and bark.
  • Enclosed grease and ash management. Weber says the job is done without reaching for a shop vacuum.
  • Plated steel cooking grates. Published as such in the specification list.
  • Crafted compatibility. A frame kit opens the smoker to griddles, sear grates and a pizza stone. All are sold separately.
MetricFigureWhat it means
Cooking area595 sq in primary, 323 warming rack, 918 totalThe two halves sum exactly, which is rarer than it should be.
Maximum temperature500, published as the maximumNo minimum is published, and SmokeBoost carries no figure.
ControllerWeber Connect LCD with Rapid React PIDIt claims temperature in 15 minutes under lab conditions.
ConnectivityWi-Fi and Bluetooth, via the Weber Connect appMonitoring works from indoors on a long cook.
Probes2 meat probes includedTwo cuts can be watched without buying anything.
Assembled size44.5 x 50.75 x 22.5 in closed, 110 lbOpening the lid needs 60 inches of headroom.
Warranty5 years cook box, 3 years electrics and fire partsWhat burns and moves carries the shorter term.
AccessoriesBottom shelf $89.99, folding tables $74.99 to $99.99A shelf is extra on a smoker costing $899.00.

Heat and cooking performance

The controller is the product. A PID measures, predicts and corrects. A good one holds its set point through weather and lid openings.

Weber puts a number on the warm-up. Temperature in 15 minutes or less. The asterisk names lab conditions, 77 degrees ambient, on Weber pellets.

That asterisk matters. A winter cook in a wind will not see that figure. Weber is honest to print the condition.

Then the ceiling. Weber publishes 500 as the maximum grill temperature. Nothing on the page describes a sear zone.

For the cooking this machine is built around, 500 is ample. Brisket, ribs, pork shoulder and roast chicken all live far below it.

Roasting is the range most owners underuse. A bird at 375 comes out of a pellet cooker tasting of the wood it burned.

For a steak crust it is not. Pellet smokers rarely sear well, and Weber does not pretend otherwise here.

That honesty is worth something. A machine that claimed both would be overselling one of them.

The practical answer is to own something else for steak. Plenty of Smoque owners keep a kettle beside it.

SmokeBoost is the more interesting setting. It holds low temperatures deliberately, because smoke sticks to cool food rather than hot.

That is real physics rather than marketing. Smoke compounds condense onto a cold surface and stop sticking once the meat warms through.

Running an hour on SmokeBoost before raising the temperature is how bark gets built.

What Weber never publishes is the figure it holds. The setting is named and described, and its temperature stays unstated.

Build, handling and durability

The machine reads solid at 110 pounds. Two all-weather wheels take one end, and the other stands on feet.

What Weber does not publish is what the body is made of. The warranty names a cook box; the specification never says its material.

Weber specifies plated steel grates, not cast iron. That heats faster, weighs less, and holds heat less well.

The warranty is where a buyer should slow down. Five years covers the cook box and everything not listed elsewhere.

Three years covers the electrical components. That same three years reaches the grates, the pellet slide and the burn pot. It reaches the heat baffle, pellet grate and controller bezel too.

Read that list again. That list is the burn pot, the auger path, the baffle and the controller. It is nearly everything that does work.

The box gets five years. The machinery inside it gets three.

None of that means the smoker is fragile. It means Weber has priced its own confidence, part by part.

Register the purchase and keep the paperwork. On a machine with an auger and a controller, the three-year list is what matters.

Running costs, upkeep and value

Pellets are the running cost, and Weber sells five blends at $19.99 each. Those are GrillMaster, Apple, Hickory, Cherry and Mesquite. Any hardwood pellet fits, so nothing locks a buyer in.

What cannot be planned is consumption. Weber publishes no hopper capacity and no burn rate anywhere on this page.

Both figures vary with weather and set temperature, which is a fair reason to hedge. It is not a reason to omit them entirely.

For a cooker sold on unattended overnight cooks, that is a real gap. Refill intervals are the thing an overnight cook needs to know.

Upkeep is genuinely better than the category norm. Grease and ash stay enclosed, and Weber says a shop vacuum never comes out.

Anyone who has emptied a fire pot by hand knows why that sentence sells smokers.

Value sits in the area. Reduced from $999.00 to $899.00, it brings 918 square inches and two probes. Nothing further is needed to start.

The accessory ladder is steep though. A bottom shelf is $89.99 and folding tables run $74.99 to $99.99.

A shelf at that price reads as an omission rather than an upgrade.

The same is true of the side tables. At 50.75 inches wide there is nowhere to rest a tray.

Weber publishes one side table as standard in the specification list. Anything beyond that is a purchase.

Possible Weber Smoque XL Complaints

The warranty split is the strongest complaint. Everything that burns or moves carries three years, and the box around it carries five.

The unpublished hopper capacity is the second. A smoker sold on long cooks should say how long it runs unattended.

Third is small and telling. The owner support block here is written for Searwood customers. Searwood is a different Weber pellet line.

The verdict
7.7/10

How we scored the Weber Smoque XL Pellet Smoker

Six categories on a fixed weighting, applied the same way to every grill. How we score.

Heat Performance 7.5
Weight 25%

A Rapid React PID holds a set temperature well, but 500 is the published ceiling and no sear story exists.

Long-term Reliability 6.5
Weight 20%

Three years covers the burn pot, pellet slide, baffle, grates and electrics. Only the box gets five.

Build Quality 7.5
Weight 18%

110 pounds on two all-weather wheels, though the grates are plated steel and no body material is published.

Ease of Use 9.0
Weight 15%

Both meat probes, the LCD controller and Wi-Fi arrive in the carton, so a first cook needs no extra purchase.

Value 8.0
Weight 12%

Reduced from $999.00 to $899.00 for 918 square inches, with probes and app control already included.

Maintenance 8.5
Weight 10%

Grease and ash are enclosed, and Weber says no shop vacuum is needed for either.

Best for

  • Long Cooks You Sleep Through Two probes and a PID controller mean the smoker watches itself. Wi-Fi puts the readout on a phone indoors. A brisket can run overnight without anybody standing beside it.
  • Cooks Feeding A Crowd There are 595 square inches on the main grate alone. The warming rack adds another 323 above it. That is room for several racks of ribs at once.
  • People Who Hate The Ash Chore Weber encloses the grease and ash system on this smoker. No shop vacuum is needed, according to the page. That is the job most pellet owners quietly dread.

Skip it if

  • You want to sear on it Weber publishes 500 as the maximum temperature. Nothing on the page describes a sear zone or a high setting beyond it. This is a smoker with a roasting range attached.
  • You need the hopper figure before buying Weber publishes no pellet capacity for this smoker anywhere. There is no consumption rate either. Planning a long cook means guessing at refills.

Bottom line

The Smoque XL is the Weber pellet argument scaled up rather than sharpened. More grate, the same 500 ceiling, and two probes already in the carton. Just read the three-year list before the five-year headline, because that list is the machine.

Weber Smoque XL Pellet Smoker Review
Check Price On AMAZON →