Smoker Reviews

Cookers built for long, low, indirect heat rather than for searing.

10 reviewed — 5 charcoal, 5 pellet. Highest scoring is Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 18 at 8.4.

All reviews Compare on all six scores All ways to browse

Broil King 923610 charcoal cabinet smoker at an angle, two latched doors, door thermometer, round side dampers

Broil King Charcoal Cabinet Smoker Review

Charcoal smoker 7.7/10

Cuisinart CPG-256 portable wood pellet grill, lid closed and latched, stainless carry handle above a lit control panel

Cuisinart CPG-256 Review

Pellet smoker 8.0/10

Cuisinart COS-118 vertical charcoal smoker, black enamel body on three splayed legs, lid thermometer and latched door.

Cuisinart COS-118 Review

Charcoal smoker 7.9/10

Black Nexgrill Oakford pellet barrel on a wet gravel pad by a hedge, front table down, controller lit

Nexgrill Oakford 28A Pellet Grill Smoker Review

Pellet smoker 7.6/10

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 22 standing on gravel, black barrel, aluminum fuel door, lid thermometer

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 22 Review

Charcoal smoker 8.2/10

Black Nexgrill Oakford pellet barrel on paving beside a raised vegetable bed, grease bucket hanging, sheets on a line

Nexgrill Oakford 36A Pellet Grill Smoker Review

Pellet smoker 7.8/10

weber smokey mountain cooker smoker 18 review

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 18 Review

Charcoal smoker 8.4/10

Black Weber Smoque XL pellet smoker on gravel beside a lawn, lid closed, lit controller on the right hopper, red stripe below

Weber Smoque XL Pellet Smoker Review

Pellet smoker 8.2/10

weber smokey mountain cooker smoker 14 review

Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 14 Review

Charcoal smoker 8.3/10

Weber Smoque pellet smoker on gravel beside a lawn, lid closed, side hopper and LCD controller to the right

Weber Smoque Pellet Smoker Review

Pellet smoker 8.1/10