Fire Magic Choice Multi-User CM650i Built-In Grill Review

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

A built-in grill head is a hole in a wall before it is a grill. The Fire Magic Choice Multi-User CM650i is 36 inches of stainless steel that drops into masonry. It is built for courtyards and pool decks, where several households share one cooker.

Fire Magic sells the same head at 24 and 30 inches. Open the parts list and the reason is plain. These three burners carry the same part number as the two in the CM430i. Same burner, same drilling, one more of it.

So nothing under this hood is new. It is the same fire, repeated. The question worth answering is what the extra foot of width actually buys.

69,000 BTUMain burner output
648 sq inPrimary cooking surface
106 BTU/sq inHeat density, same as the 24-inch model
37 3/4 inCutout width the masonry must give

First Impressions of the Fire Magic CM650i

You never meet this grill loose. A qualified professional installer sets it into a poured island. Fire Magic makes that installation a warranty condition. Nobody cooks on a CM650i the day it arrives.

Once it sits flush, width is the whole first impression. Three knobs run across a control panel 38 1/4 inches wide. Satin stainless, no polish, no trim. It looks like something ordered by a facilities manager.

The control panel carries most of the character. Knobs are heavy, round and deeply knurled. The drip tray slides out from underneath without tools. Everything you touch feels heavier than it needs to be.

Lift the hood and the money shows. Spring assist carries the weight, and it stops open at 90 degrees. Nothing on this grill plugs in. Press a knob, turn it to HI LIGHT, and a spark fires from inside the control.

The first cook across all three burners explains the size. Thirty six inches of Diamond Sear grid holds a full run of thighs. A tray of peppers goes on beside them, over the third burner. The food tastes as it does on the 24-inch model, which is rather the point.

Key Features of the Fire Magic CM650i

The Multi-User set is what separates this from a plain Choice grill. Every one of those features sits on the 24-inch model too. Buying the 36 buys width, not a different specification.

  • Three matched main burners: Part 3042-60, three of them, 23,000 BTU each. The 24-inch model uses two of the same part.
  • Stainless steel: Double-walled 304 stainless hood and housing. Beneath the grids sit 16-gauge 304 stainless Flavor Grids.
  • Diamond Sear cooking grids: Patented under D857,453 and D862,984. An anti-theft locking mechanism holds them where they belong.
  • Push-button igniter: The spark lives inside each knob. There is no power connection and no battery anywhere on the grill.
  • Anti-theft warming rack: 36 by 8 inches, 288 square inches of it. Two hook positions give a cooking height and a storage height.
  • One-hour shutoff timer: A timer in its own stainless box cuts the gas. Shared courtyards get a backstop against a knob left open.
  • Analog thermometer: An angled dial in a polished stainless bezel sits in the hood. Nothing to calibrate, nothing to power.
  • Made in USA: R. H. Peterson builds these in City of Industry, California.
MetricFigureWhat it means
Cooking area648 sq in main, 288 sq in warming rackFire Magic lists the two surfaces separately, and so do we.
Burner output69,000 BTU across three burnersThat works out at 23,000 BTU per burner.
Heat density106 BTU per square inchIdentical to the 24-inch CM430i in the same line.
Cutout37 3/4 in w x 19 1/2 in d x 11 1/2 in hNon-combustible enclosures only. A liner changes these figures.
Weight200 lbs, dealer-listedTwo people and a plan, never one person and optimism.
Gas supply1/2 in minimum pipe, shut-off valve within 6 feetA plumbing job that happens before the grill arrives.
WarrantyLifetime burners, grids and housing in residential useShared installs fall under a separate multi-user document.
ShippingFree on most dealer orders above $1,000Freight terms come from the dealer, not from Fire Magic.

Heat and cooking performance

69,000 BTU reads like a step up from the 24-inch model’s 46,000. Spread it across the grid and the step disappears. This grill gives 106 BTU per square inch. The CM430i gives the same 106.

That is not a coincidence. Fire Magic uses one burner across the whole Choice line, drilled to one size. The 36-inch model gets three of them where the 24 gets two. This is not a hotter grill, it is the same fire, wider.

What the third burner does buy is a zone. Two burners force a blunt choice: half the grid hot, half of it dead. Three let you close one end and keep two running. Ribs can sit over a shut burner while steaks sear a foot away.

The grid itself does more work than the output figure suggests. Diamond Sear bars are broad and flat across the top. They lay a wide mark on a steak instead of a thin line. Fat falling through hits the Flavor Grids and returns as smoke.

Depth is where the upgrade stops. The cooking surface stays 18 inches front to back on all three widths. Hood height does not change either. You can cook more at once, never anything taller.

Build, handling and durability

Double-walled 304 stainless is most of the construction story. Almost nothing on it moves, so almost nothing can loosen. Only the hood does, and spring assist carries it to a stop at 90 degrees.

The parts list is the real durability argument. Ten of the components most likely to wear are shared across every Choice width. Regulator PR-4, drip tray 3093 and knob 3026 carry over from the 24-inch model. Igniter 3199-50 and valve 3025 do too.

That matters more in a shared courtyard than in a backyard. A property running two or three sizes stocks a single bin of spares. Only the obvious pieces change with width. Grid set 3542-DS-3, Flavor Grids 3065-S-3, manifold 24181-12 and lid 23734-50.

Height and depth are shared with the rest of the line as well. The head stands 20 3/4 inches with the hood open and 13 5/8 inches shut. Maximum depth is 25 3/4 inches on a 24 and on a 36. Only width and weight move.

Weather is handled by material rather than by accessories. Nothing is supplied to shield it, and wind is a real constraint. The manual allows 15 minutes of full output behind a closed lid, no more.

Running costs, upkeep and value

There is no Fire Magic price to quote. Its product pages send you to a dealer instead. Flame Authority and Kickass Grills both listed the CM650i-RT1N at $5,157.00 on 27 August 2026. No manufacturer number stands behind either listing.

The step up from the 24-inch model came to $966.60 at the same dealer that day. Half again as much grilling surface arrives with it. Per square inch, the 36 works out at $7.96 against $9.70 for the CM430i.

Gas sizing deserves a thought before anyone pours concrete. Supply pipe wants a 1/2 inch bore as a minimum. Runs longer than 20 feet may need something larger. Three burners at full output are not a small draw.

Upkeep is a routine rather than a project. Ten to fifteen minutes at full output burns the grease off, then brush. The drip tray pulls out and takes disposable liners. Flavor Grids catch fat before it ever reaches a burner.

What the price does not cover is the enclosure and its fittings. A combustible island needs insulating liner 3177-52. An enclosed cooking bay needs a 42-VH-7 vent hood. Both smaller Choice grills take the 36-VH-7 instead.

Possible Fire Magic CM650i Complaints

  • The width is a building decision, not a buying one: Masonry has to be cut to 37 3/4 inches, or 38 3/4 where a countertop overhangs. Enclose it and the vent hood steps up to a 42-VH-7. Once the island is poured, changing your mind means rebuilding it.
  • The extra foot buys no depth and no headroom: The grid stays 18 inches front to back, exactly as on the 24-inch model. Hood height is identical right across the line. A tall roast fits no better here. The third zone has to do that work instead.
The verdict
8.1/10

How we scored the Fire Magic Choice Multi-User CM650i Built-In Grill

Six categories on a fixed weighting, applied the same way to every grill. How we score.

Heat Performance 8.3
Weight 25%

Three separately valved 23,000 BTU burners over 648 square inches give a genuine off zone without surrendering half the grid.

Long-term Reliability 9.3
Weight 20%

Burners, grids and housing carry lifetime residential coverage, and ten wear parts are shared across every width in the Choice line.

Build Quality 8.4
Weight 18%

Double-walled 304 stainless and 16-gauge burners, though Fire Magic contradicts itself on burner gauge and this is its entry line.

Ease of Use 6.2
Weight 15%

Owners cannot install it, cannot claim labor, and cannot move 200 pounds of grill head without help.

Value 7.9
Weight 12%

Cheaper per square inch than the 24-inch model, but dealer money buys Fire Magic's most basic feature set.

Maintenance 8.2
Weight 10%

Flavor Grids and a lined pull-out drip tray keep fat off the burners, with a grid lifter supplied.

Best for

  • Condo Boards With One Grill And Forty Owners Locking knobs, a locked warming rack and grids that will not walk off. A timer in a stainless box shuts the gas after an hour. Three zones let two households cook at once without negotiating.
  • Island Builders Working To A Drawing The cutout is published to the eighth of an inch. Depth matches the smaller models exactly. A mason can pour to it before the grill ever ships.
  • Cooks Who Want A Real Off Zone Two burners make indirect cooking a choice between hot and dead. Three let you shut one end and keep searing. Ribs at one side, steaks at the other, on one grid.

Skip it if

  • You want a bigger grill, not a wider one The grid stays 18 inches front to back, exactly as on the 24-inch model. Hood height does not change either. Nothing fits under this lid that would not fit under that one.
  • You expected to install it yourself A qualified professional installer is a warranty condition, not a suggestion. Labor is not covered on a claim. The saving you hoped to make by doing it yourself is not available.

Bottom line

Fire Magic scaled this line by repeating a burner rather than designing a bigger one. So the CM650i cooks at exactly the CM430i’s intensity, over half again the grid. The third zone is the real purchase, and it is what makes indirect cooking honest.

Fire Magic Choice Multi-User CM650i Built-In Grill Review
Check Price On AMAZON →